twitter twitter  twitter twitter twitter twitter twitter twitter  twitter twitter 

Private Palestinian Land Can Be Taken for Public Use in Settlements, Israeli Attorney General Says

0
0
0
s2smodern

Mendelblit shifts position based on recent Supreme Court ruling stating that expropriation is acceptable since Israeli settlers are also part of West Bank's ‘local population’

Privately owned Palestinian land may be expropriated for public purposes in West Bank Jewish settlements, Attorney General Avichai Mendelblit asserted in a legal opinion released Wednesday.
The opinion came in light of a court decision several weeks ago by Supreme Court Justice Salim Joubran, who ruled that land could be seized for the benefit of Israeli settlers because they, too, were part of West Bank’s “local population.” According to Mendelblit, privately owned Palestinian land can now be expropriated for public purposes in settlements, although such steps still must comply with standards of reasonableness and proportionality as well as other laws, including planning laws.


The attorney general’s legal opinion was issued at the request of Justice Minister Ayelet Shaked and is connected to a request to legalize an access path to the illegal Jewish outpost of Harsha, located near Ramallah in the West Bank. A portion of the path sits on privately owned Palestinian land, and the absence of legal access to Harsha is the main reason that the outpost had not yet been authorized.
In the wake of Joubran’s ruling, Shaked asked the attorney general to reconsider his position on the expropriation of land at the outpost. In the past, Mendelblit opposed the expropriation of private Palestinian land at Harsha. In Wednesday’s legal opinion, Mendelblit shifted his position to be in line with Joubran’s ruling.
In February, the attorney general had said that recommending to authorize the road would present legal difficulties because it would only in use by the West Bank’s Jewish population. On Wednesday, he wrote in his opinion that although the full implications of Joubran’s ruling would require further study, it would now be possible to legalize the access road leading to the outpost.
“The full significance of [Joubran’s] ruling will be examined by the attorney general in the near future in a [formal] legal opinion,” Mendelblit wrote. At the same time, he wrote, there are no longer legal grounds that prevent, in principle, the legalization of the access road for public purposes through expropriation.
That being said, Mendelblit cautioned, his legal opinion only meant that there was general legal authority to expropriate land for purposes such as an access road to Harsha. Any actual expropriation must still be considered based on the principles of proportionality and reasonableness, he wrote, and these issues that must still be examined. In addition, any decision to legalize such an access path is not exempt from planning requirements based on local law and “the rules of public law.”
Joubran’s ruling several weeks ago related to an effort to head off the evacuation of the West Bank Amona outpost at the beginning of the year. At the time, the court ruled against the plan, which involved abandoned Palestinian land, and the evacuation took place in February 2017. However, in the recent ruling, Joubran expanded on his broad decision to recognize the authority of the West Bank military commander “to act for the benefit of the civilian interests of the Israeli residents” of the West Bank.
“Israelis are included among the civilian population of the area and therefore the military commander’s duty also extends to them,” Joubran wrote, citing a prior ruling by former Justice Aharon Barak, who noted: “Israelis in the area have the right to life, dignity, property and all the rights enjoyed by anyone in Israel.”
In response to Mendelblit’s legal opinion released on Wednesday, Justice Minister Shaked, who is part of the right-wing Habayit Hayehudi party, said: “The attorney general has issued a legal opinion permitting the expropriation of privately owned Palestinian land to permit an access road to [Harsha] that permits the regulation [legalization] of the entire [settlement]. The justice minister welcomes the decision, which is another step in exercising the rights of the hundreds of thousands of [Israeli] residents of Judea and Samaria [the West Bank], and she will continue to advance a reexamination of prior legal positions relating to the regulation of construction in Judea and Samaria.”

Yotam Berger

Haaretz Correspondent

read more: https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/.premium-1.823001

Private Palestinian Land Can Be Taken for Public Use in Settlements Israeli Attorney General Says

Tags: #NAKBA, #Occupation, #Israeli crimes


Video Service

Video of the Week: Recent Israel History Miko Peled

Transcription made from The Miko's Speeches




This is a beautiful church so once again thank you to the pastor for allowing us to use this is really beautiful and thank you all for being here tonight and and for caring enough to take the time and listen and participate and be active I always begin my remarks with a disclaimer and that disclaimer is this if anybody here came hoping to hear a balanced presentation then they're going to be sorely disappointed I say this because a lot of things that you're about to hear tonight are difficult to hear and also because I don't believe that a balanced presentation on this topic is possible anybody that cares enough to speak about this probably has a very strong opinion one way or the other almost everybody has feelings and strong emotions on this issue one way or the other for me it's deeply personal and the issue itself is not a balanced issue there is no balance in this issue so therefore I say this because there cannot be a balanced presentation on this and I think if anybody claims that their presentation is balanced they're either misleading themselves or the misleading of their audience this whole issue of Israel and Palestine is covered in so much myth and there's so much there's so much double standard when people talk about this issue and I'll give you two examples

Don't know if you heard Bibi Netanyahu speech at the United Nations I heard it not live but after he actually delivered it and he began and he began it with probably the two most striking examples of myth and double standard and he began by talking about the right of return of the Jews to their ancient homeland and of course the Jews that returned so-called returned to their homeland were not exactly the the same Jews who were expelled from their homeland right because these were expelled a couple of thousand years before that these were not their descendants either because they this is business has been a very long time so these are people the people that actually came back so to speak are people that claim some kind of a heritage some kind of a connection a relationship to the ancient Hebrews and they claimed that they had the right to return to their homeland and this was this is what Zionism was about and this is expected this was you know accepted by the world as the right they had the right to return now if we talk about the right of return of one nation you'd expect that there would be if we accept it as a principle than

Read More>>>>>>>>

Boycott Israeli diamond

At UN Abbas Calls on World Leaders to Recognize Palestinian State

                       

                       

Read more ...

Putin s Phone Call With Netanyahu Blew Whistle on Further Israeli Strikes in Syria

                         

                         

Read more ...

Settlers Caught on Film Throwing Stones at Left wing Activists in West Bank

                         

                         

Read more ...

Israel Will Not Release Palestinian Teen Who Slapped Soldier Until Trial End

                      

                      

Read more ...

Apocalypse Now? At Armageddon Some Topics Are Best Avoided Around Jews

                          

                         

Read more ...

Childs killers Kuwaiti speaker pointed towards the Israeli representative at the international forum

                           

                           

'Childs' killers; Kuwaiti speaker pointed towards the Israeli representative at the international forum

Read more ...